Mariah Carey just received the ultimate Christmas gift — a courtroom victory and $92,000 in legal fees after winning her copyright battle over the holiday classic “All I Want For Christmas Is You.” Three decades later, the Queen of Christmas proves that her timeless hit remains undefeated — on the charts and in court
Mariah Carey is celebrating what fans are calling her real-life “Christmas miracle.” The pop icon has officially won her legal battle over “All I Want For Christmas Is You”, securing a $92,000 award after a federal court dismissed a $20 million lawsuit accusing her of plagiarism.
The case was filed by country singer Andy Stone, best known from Vince Vance & the Valiants, who claimed Carey’s 1994 global hit copied his 1988 song of the same name. However, U.S. District Judge Monica Ramírez Almadani ruled that Stone’s complaint lacked evidence, calling it “legally baseless and procedurally abusive.”
The court not only dismissed the case but also ordered Stone and his legal team to pay more than $109,000 in damages — $92,300 of which goes directly to Carey to cover her legal expenses. The decision also included sanctions against Stone’s attorneys for what the judge described as “unsubstantiated and reckless litigation tactics.”
Though Carey herself has not made a formal statement, sources close to the singer say she was “relieved and grateful” for the outcome, reportedly telling friends, “Justice prevailed.” For Mariah, this wasn’t just about a legal win — it was about defending her artistic integrity and protecting one of the most beloved songs of all time.
The ruling strengthens Carey’s long-standing title as the “Queen of Christmas.” “All I Want For Christmas Is You” continues to dominate charts every December, returning to No.1 on Billboard year after year. Since its release in 1994, the track has become a holiday staple, generating over $75 million in royalties and earning multiple Guinness World Records.
The court’s decision also sends a broader message about intellectual property and artistic credibility in the digital era. In her verdict, Judge Almadani emphasized that the lawsuit represented a “misuse of the legal system” and should serve as a cautionary example for future opportunistic claims.
Meanwhile, Carey continues to dazzle audiences with her sold-out Las Vegas residency “Christmastime in Las Vegas.” Each night, she closes her show with a snow-filled performance of “All I Want For Christmas Is You,” reminding fans that the magic of the season will forever sound like her voice.
This case highlights a universal truth: great songs — and great artists — endure. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or simply find yourself smiling when those opening bells play, there’s no denying the cultural power of Carey’s holiday anthem.
As Christmas approaches, “All I Want For Christmas Is You” once again fills playlists, malls, and hearts worldwide. And this year, it comes with an extra sparkle — the satisfaction of a well-earned victory.
